Skip to main content

A Sad Death on Keilor Road

While Dad didn't talk about his uncles, aunts and cousins on the Phelan side too often, he did recall - in fact, my recollection is that Mum remembered at least as well as Dad - that his Uncle Bill (William Anthony Phelan) had too sons: Peter and Kevin. Strangely, they forgot to tell me that there was another son, also named William Anthony, but known as Tony. Yes, that's right - another Anthony Phelan, you would think that he would have remembered him! :) In fact since I started this research and coming into contact with more Phelans, I have actually met Tony's daughter Robyn (so, my second cousin) on a few occasions, and she is quite interested in all of this stuff too, so hi to Robyn if you are reading!

But back to the story. The reason I remember Mum and Dad telling me about Dad's cousin Peter Phelan so distinctly was that they told me he had died, quite young, in a car accident. This tragic event happened in 1958, when Peter, who was a printer, was just 27 years old. The Public Records Office Victoria holds the inquest into Peter's death, so I was able to uncover just what unfolded. 

On Sunday 10th August Peter Phelan had been playing golf at Gisborne with two friends, Carlyle Ryan and Arthur Sowden. travelling in Ryan's Volkswagen. At the inquest, Ryan admitted to having a few beers after the round. Sowden said he had three beers with a meal, but couldn't say how many Ryan had. They left Gisborne around dusk to return to Melbourne, Ryan driving, Phelan in the front passenger seat, and Sowden in the rear. Sowden promptly dozed off. At around 7pm they reached Niddrie and were travelling along Keilor Road in an easterly direction when Ryan became aware of an obstruction across the road and 'swerved violently to [the] right and accelerated' in an effort to avoid the obstruction, which turned out to be a semi-trailer backing out from the northern side of the road. The nearside of his car (the side on which Peter was seated) struck the rear of the semi, mounted the southern footpath and came to rest against a factory wall further along the road. Ryan suffered head wounds and was knocked out but regained consciousness. Sowden, who had still been dozing at the time of impact, also suffered cuts to his face but was able to leave the vehicle to request assistance from a woman in a nearby shop. Peter had also been knocked out, and was still in an unconscious state when all three were taken by ambulance to the Royal Melbourne Hospital, arriving about 8pm. Dr. Neil Bromberger found that Peter had sustained extensive facial injuries as well as a fracture of the skull on the left fractal regions. He would pass away at about 10.30pm, the doctor stating the cause as 'extensive brain damage resulting from the blow to the head'.

The statements made by other witnesses to the inquest are more revealing. Henry Gorny had pulled his car up as he had seen the semi-trailer, whose lights were on, commencing to reverse out onto the road, he gave a hand signal to indicate he had stopped, and at least two other cars pulled up behind him. The second of those cars was driven by Ian Jensen, who was driving a higher vehicle and admitted that he had to brake a little suddenly. Before he had fully stopped, Ryan's car swung out from behind and came flying past him at a speed of about 40-45 mph and did not appear to slow down before colliding with the rear of the semi. Edward Carroll, the driver of the semi, was exercising caution when backing out as he expected that people would be returning from the country on a Sunday evening. He proceeded with his reversing onto the road as he had seen the first two cars pull up. John Sinnott, who had been travelling in the opposite direction had seen the semi but did not believe it was adequately lighted, he thought it was a bit dangerous which is why he looked back after passing it and witnessed the crash.

Constable Desmond Dever attended the scene of the accident and his view was that the accident was caused by negligence on the part of Carlyle Ryan failing to notice the semi-trailer backing out of the driveway (although interestingly, in the original hand-written statement, this sentence was lightly crossed out). I sense that the sudden braking of the car in front and the fact that it may have blocked vision of the semi might have contributed to what eventuated, but knowing what we know now about the effects of alcohol, it feels overwhelmingly likely that the effect of the beers consumed was directly related to the speed of the car and the delayed reaction time of its driver. Unsurprisingly, the inquest found that Peter Phelan had died from 'the effects of injuries received by misadventure... when the motor vehicle in which he was a passenger... came into collision with another motor vehicle... and then ran into the wall of a building".

Peter's death came less than two years after a serious injury to his brother Kevin Joseph Phelan. On New Years Eve of 1956, while working at his job on the railways, Kevin suffered a fractured spine and lacerations to his scalp and face after being caught between two trains travelling in opposite directions near West Melbourne Stadium (the current Festival Hall).



Keilor Rd, Niddrie, the scene of the accident in 1958


Edward Carroll's semi-trailer, which was struck by the car driven by Carlyle Ryan


Ryan's Volkswagen, showing the damage sustained to the front passenger side where Peter Phelan was seated




Comments

Popular posts from this blog

General Hewitt and the Man from Elba

I have always enjoyed saying I'm 1/16th Italian. I've often been asked if I have a European background, so it's fun to be able to provide that answer. Though so far, my DNA test is showing no evidence of this background! Nevertheless, it is true, my family does have one Italian ancestor. He was my 2x great-grandfather and his name was Antony Gasperino. His arrival in this country dates back to the 1850s, in quite unusual circumstances, on a ship named the General Hewitt . But before we even make our way on board that ship, what little we know of Antony's early life deserves a mention. Antony (presumably Antonio in his native land) Gasperino was born on the island of Elba in 1836. From his marriage certificate we know that his father was Lawrence (Lorenzo) Gasperino but his mother's name is not recorded. On his death certificate her name is listed as 'not known'. It's strange that even the informant at the time of his death (his son Joseph) would not kno...

How Austin Phelan Met his Wife

Dad's father Phillip Stanley Phelan was one of twelve children (eight boys and four girls) born to Joseph Phelan and Mary Gasperino. By the time Dad was eight years old, he had five uncles and three aunts surviving. As I have mentioned previously, I don't recall hearing much about them from him when I was growing up, and certainly not Austin George Phelan, who was the youngest of the boys in the family. Austin was born in Benalla in 1904, lived in the Essendon area all his life, like many of the Phelan clan, and worked as a brewery employee. But it is how he came to meet his wife Sara that proved to be of most interest once I started digging.  As you can see above, Austin was listed as the 'co-respondent' in the 1931 divorce case between John Carnegie Lovick and his wife Sara Annie Lovick. In other words, he was the 'other man' who had become involved with a married woman (who would later ultimately become his wife). Officially John Lovick was petitioning...

Three Phelan Brothers in the Great War

As a youngster I was told that my grandfather, Phillip Stanley Phelan, had been a Prisoner of War in the First World War but that was about the extent of the story. I never knew my grandfather, and chances are that even if I had, I might not have got many details from him, as plenty of men who lived through that horrific experience didn't like to talk about it. Even when my interest in genealogy began I didn't have a huge interest in the war. However once I got looking at the records, I wanted to make sense of them and began to delve deeper into the stories. While Stan is my only direct ancestor to have served in the conflict, he was one of three sons of Joseph Phelan who enlisted, one of whom would pay the ultimate price. I also discovered many more relatives on Dad's side of the family who took part. One day I may write something more comprehensive about the experiences of all my relatives who served - there were many on Mum's side as well - but for now my post will ...